Comments on: More Information per Pixel! ../../../../2008/07/more-information-per-pixel-2/ XLCubed Blog Thu, 10 Jan 2019 09:13:58 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.3.21 By: Heatmap Tables with Excel – Revisited – blog.xlcubed.com ../../../../2008/07/more-information-per-pixel-2/#comment-71 Mon, 11 Jul 2011 11:04:07 +0000 http://blog.xlcubed.com/?p=288#comment-71 […] […]

]]>
By: Andreas Lipphardt ../../../../2008/07/more-information-per-pixel-2/#comment-70 Sat, 02 Aug 2008 11:00:42 +0000 http://blog.xlcubed.com/?p=288#comment-70 Jerome,

As Jon suggested, why not handing out high resolution print outs of information dense, complex slides?

I can understand your point but also have to admin that I still find Rolfs Presentation Philosophy convincing. Let me cite from Rolf Hichert’s Info Design Booklet http://www.hichert.com/Download/Brochure.pdf

“Slides are easier to understand and conducive to identifying relationships and dependencies when they have a high level of information density: It is easier to analyze four charts that belong together if they are arranged next to each other on one page than if they are displayed on four consecutive pages. The more that can be shown together, the faster complex topics can be understood. A measure of information density is the number of numerical values represented per area.

The current ‘PowerPoint culture’ too often results in the opposite: where it is not the illustrations that “do the talking” (as a result of their low information density), rather the speakers must explain them.

Don’t leave anything out: when possible ‘everything’ must be displayed […]”

Andreas

]]>
By: Jerome ../../../../2008/07/more-information-per-pixel-2/#comment-69 Mon, 28 Jul 2008 13:56:34 +0000 http://blog.xlcubed.com/?p=288#comment-69 Hello Andreas,
I understand what you mean. I still argue that this level of precision belongs to reports, dashboards and other written documents.

In a presentation, the key is to get the message across. The only way is to grab the audience’s attention and get them to follow your logic as you unfold your presentation.

Anything that can detract from your key message is like cracks through which your audience attention will flow like water.

Case in point with this exhibit. Let’s suppose we are showing that in a board meeting. We would like our audience to agree that business is good in Frankfurt, Vienna and Graz, but needs support in Lausanne and Linz.
By the time we say that, our audience would have looked at the other 10 graphs and noticed that in most locales there has been a sharp drop in gross margin in the recent years, although they are not emphasised in red. At this point they are probably thinking something like, Linz and Lausanne are no big news, but how come our margin has been halved in Paris or Berne in the last 2 years and why aren’t we focussing our efforts on them instead? meanwhile, they are not listening to what you are saying.

In a presentation, offering your audience data that doesn’t support your point, or that weakens it, is really shooting oneself a bullet in the foot.

In that case, I would have opted for a simple bar chart with difference in gross margin between 2007 and 1997 in the 15 locales. Vienna will be first (+17) followed by Frankfurt and Graz, while Lausanne and Berlin would be last.

Because more detailed information would be available to my audience in a written form, that wouldn’t save me from embarassing questions at the end of the presentation but I would still keep them onboard until my last slide.

]]>
By: Nice Dashboard Examples » PTS Blog ../../../../2008/07/more-information-per-pixel-2/#comment-68 Wed, 16 Jul 2008 15:12:23 +0000 http://blog.xlcubed.com/?p=288#comment-68 […] More Information per Pixel!, they display a very nice report by Professor Rolf […]

]]>
By: Jon Peltier ../../../../2008/07/more-information-per-pixel-2/#comment-67 Wed, 16 Jul 2008 14:58:05 +0000 http://blog.xlcubed.com/?p=288#comment-67 Rolf’s dashboard report is very nicely done. I’d remove the gray lines at the top and bottom edges of the red and green colored bands, but otherwise it is very effective.

I’m not sure whether this would be as effective in a presentation, unless the audience had been given handouts ahead of time.

]]>